Souls Crossover X Reforge Guide – Chances, Damage Bonuses

Reforging is one of the easiest ways to increase your damage in Souls Crossover X, but it is also one of the biggest gem sinks in the game. When I first started using the system, I assumed I could keep rolling until I landed something amazing. After spending quite a few gems, I quickly realised that RNG can be incredibly unforgiving. Sometimes you’ll improve your weapon in just a couple of rolls, while other times you’ll spend dozens of gems only to end up with a worse modifier than when you started.

If you’re a beginner, understanding how reforging actually works before spending your gems will save you a lot of frustration. This guide explains everything you need to know, including every reforge tier, their chances, damage bonuses, supported equipment, and the smartest way to use your gems.

Souls Crossover X Reforge Guide – Reforging

Reforging is a feature that allows you to randomly change the damage modifier on certain tools and spells.

Every time you reforge an item, the game randomly selects one of the available reforge tiers. Each tier provides either a damage increase or, if you’re unlucky, a damage reduction.

Unlike upgrading equipment, reforging does not guarantee an improvement. Every roll is completely based on RNG, meaning your favourite weapon can become much stronger—or noticeably weaker.

Because of this, reforging is always a gamble rather than a guaranteed upgrade.

Reforge Location

You can access the Reforge NPC inside the main spawn lobby.

Look around the lobby until you find the NPC inspired by Frisk. The NPC has “Reforge” displayed above their head, making it fairly easy to spot.

Simply interact with the NPC, select a compatible tool or spell, and spend gems to begin rolling for a new modifier.

Reforge Cost

Each reforge attempt costs:

  • 5 Gems per roll

There are no discounts or guarantees after multiple attempts. Whether it’s your first roll or your hundredth, every attempt still costs five gems and uses the exact same odds.

RNG System

One mistake many beginners make is thinking the game slowly improves their chances after several bad rolls.

That isn’t how the system works.

Every reforge is completely independent.

For example:

  • Rolling Broken five times doesn’t make Legendary more likely.
  • Getting an Epic doesn’t reduce your chance of another Epic.
  • Every roll starts fresh using the same probability table.

That’s why some players get Mythical within a few attempts, while others spend hundreds of gems without ever seeing one.

Complete Reforge Tier List

There are nine possible reforge results, ranging from terrible negative modifiers to incredibly rare endgame bonuses.

Broken

  • Chance: 15%
  • Damage: -15%

Broken is easily one of the worst outcomes in the game.

Instead of increasing your damage, it actually makes your equipment weaker. Since it has a fairly high appearance rate, you’ll probably encounter it several times while reforging.

If you land Broken on your main weapon, you’ll usually want to reroll immediately.

Poor

  • Chance: 12%
  • Damage: -5%

Poor is slightly better than Broken but is still considered a negative modifier.

Your weapon loses damage instead of gaining it, making it another result that most players will want to replace as soon as possible.

Common

  • Chance: 30%
  • Damage: +5%

Common is the most frequently obtained reforge in the game.

Although a 5% damage increase doesn’t sound huge, it’s still better than having no bonus at all and significantly better than landing a negative modifier.

For newer players with limited gems, Common is actually a perfectly acceptable stopping point on mid-tier equipment.

Uncommon

  • Chance: 20%
  • Damage: +10%

Uncommon provides a noticeable jump over Common.

A 10% damage increase is enough to make combat feel smoother, especially when you’re farming enemies repeatedly.

This is another solid result that doesn’t require an excessive amount of luck.

Rare

  • Chance: 12%
  • Damage: +15%

Rare starts entering the point where your weapon feels meaningfully stronger.

Since it only appears 12% of the time, it isn’t guaranteed, but it’s still realistic to obtain without spending an absurd amount of gems.

For many players, Rare is already a good place to stop unless they’re working on their endgame gear.

Epic

  • Chance: 7%
  • Damage: +25%

Epic is a major upgrade.

Receiving a 25% damage increase can significantly improve your overall DPS, making farming bosses and difficult enemies much easier.

Because the chance drops to only 7%, don’t expect to see it consistently.

Legendary

  • Chance: 3%
  • Damage: +35%

Legendary is one of the stronger modifiers available.

Only a small percentage of reforges reach this level, making it a fantastic result for powerful weapons that you plan to use for a long time.

Most players would be very happy stopping here.

Mythical

  • Chance: 1%
  • Damage: +50%

Mythical is where the RNG starts becoming truly brutal.

With only a 1% chance, you could spend a huge amount of gems before ever seeing it.

The reward, however, is massive.

A 50% damage increase turns already powerful equipment into something capable of dealing dramatically higher damage.

Secret

  • Chance: 0.1%
  • Damage: +100%

Secret is the rarest reforge in Souls Crossover.

Only one out of roughly one thousand rolls will statistically land this modifier, although RNG means you could get lucky much sooner—or never see it at all.

Its reward is incredible.

A full 100% damage increase effectively doubles your weapon or spell’s damage output, making it the absolute best modifier in the game.

Because of its extremely low odds, most players should never expect to obtain Secret naturally.

If it happens, consider yourself incredibly lucky.

Reforge Chances

Tier Chance Damage Bonus
Broken 15% -15%
Poor 12% -5%
Common 30% +5%
Uncommon 20% +10%
Rare 12% +15%
Epic 7% +25%
Legendary 3% +35%
Mythical 1% +50%
Secret 0.1% +100%

Damage Scaling

One detail that’s easy to overlook is that reforge percentages scale with your equipment’s base damage.

For example, a 25% bonus on a weak starter weapon won’t feel nearly as impactful as a 25% bonus on one of the strongest endgame weapons.

This is why experienced players usually avoid spending large amounts of gems on temporary equipment.

The stronger the original weapon or spell, the more value you’ll gain from high-tier reforges.

Reforgeable Tools

The following tools currently support reforging:

  • Fists
  • Alfie Axe
  • Empty Gun
  • Chaos Saber
  • Torn Notebook
  • Real Knife
  • Spear
  • Stick
  • Tough Glove
  • Temp Katana
  • Dust Toy Knife
  • True Zangetsu
  • Frisk Knife
  • Zanggetsu
  • Sans Bone
  • Worn Dagger
  • Papyrus Bone
  • Spear of the Undying
  • Trident
  • Mettaton
  • Any Cannon
  • Blue Bone
  • Burnt Pan
  • Toy Knife

As new updates release, this list may expand with additional equipment.

Reforgeable Spells

Several spells can also receive reforge modifiers.

Current supported spells include:

  • Fire Shield
  • Swap
  • Burn
  • Kamehameha
  • Shard Rain
  • Bone Wall

Reforging these spells works exactly the same way as tools, with identical costs and identical RNG chances.

Gems

Since every roll costs gems, understanding where they come from is just as important as understanding reforging itself.

You can earn Gems through several activities, including:

  • Daily rewards
  • Redeem codes
  • Index completion
  • Unlocking resets

Because gems aren’t unlimited, it’s worth thinking carefully before spending them all on a single weapon.

Gem Management

One of the biggest mistakes beginners make is trying to roll Legendary or Secret on the very first decent weapon they find.

In my experience, that’s usually a waste of valuable gems.

Early-game equipment gets replaced fairly quickly, meaning those expensive rerolls won’t provide long-term value.

A much smarter approach is to save the majority of your gems until you’ve obtained weapons or spells that you know you’ll be using for a long time.

Even landing something like Rare or Epic on an endgame weapon is often more valuable than chasing Secret on gear you’ll replace in the next hour.

Patience usually pays off much more than constantly chasing perfect RNG.

Reforging Strategy

If you’re still progressing through the game, aim for reasonable upgrades instead of perfection.

Common and Uncommon already provide positive damage bonuses and are relatively easy to obtain.

Once you’ve reached stronger equipment, it’s worth investing more gems in hopes of landing Rare, Epic, Legendary, or even Mythical.

Secret should be viewed as an extremely lucky bonus rather than a realistic target.

Trying to force it can drain hundreds of gems without giving you the result you’re hoping for.

Eric Langell
Eric Langell

Eric is a Senior Writer for Treyexgaming, primarily covering guides and codes, as well as general gaming news and guides. After leaving university with a degree in Bachelor in Physical Education.

Articles: 2476