Finding every hidden event in Pinkie Promise Roblox requires exploring off the beaten path and occasionally failing objectives on purpose. While the main story tasks push you forward on a linear path through Sweet Apple Acres and the Everfree Forest, nine numbered secrets and multiple alternate endings reward experimental gameplay.
This walkthrough covers the exact dialogue choices, environmental triggers, and escape techniques needed to earn every badge and register all nine hidden secrets in your tracker.
Roblox Pinkie Promise Secrets & Badges Guide – Requirement
Badges and Secrets Overview
The game divides its achievements between progression milestones, deliberate failure conditions, and specific interaction triggers across Chapters 1 and 2.
| Badge / Secret Name | Trigger Requirement | Encounter Location |
|---|---|---|
| Out of the Fire | Herd the chickens into the coop and escape the burning farm. | Applejack’s Barn |
| Out of the Woods | Survive the Everfree Forest track chase and board the train. | Railroad Tracks |
| A Warm Welcome | Enter Sugarcube Corner alongside Pinkie Pie. | Sugarcube Corner |
| Not Found | Successfully hide from Pinkie inside a closet without being caught. | Sugarcube Corner |
| Pinkie’s Party | Eat all four bites of the party cupcake to complete Chapter 1. | Party Table |
| Kindling | Allow the barn fire timer to expire without putting out the blaze. | Applejack’s Barn |
| Lost in the Everfree | Fail an obstacle or run out of time during the track chase. | Everfree Forest |
| Found You | Get captured by Pinkie Pie while exploring the house in Chapter 2. | Upstairs Hallway |
| Secret 1: Somepony at the Window | Ask Applejack about the loft window figure in the morning dialogue. | Barn Entrance |
| Secret 2: Angry Applejack | Throw multiple buckets of water directly at Applejack instead of the fire. | Barn Courtyard |
| Secret 3: Somepony on the Train | Spot the smiling face drawn on the foggy carriage window. | Friendship Express |
| Secret 4: Not Fire! | Carry the train lantern to Fluttershy instead of collecting glowcaps. | Railroad Tracks |
| Secret 5: Spin Cycle | Let Gummy latch onto you and spin around the room. | Sugarcube Corner |
| Secret 6: Wrong Answer | Refuse to make a Pinkie Promise three consecutive times. | Kitchen Staircase |
| Secret 7: Broken Promise | Agree to the Pinkie Promise and immediately attempt to open the front exit. | Front Red Door |
| Secret 8: I Dare You | Repeatedly bump and poke Pinkie before taking your seat at the table. | Party Room |
| Secret 9: Creature of Habit | Hide in the identical closet twice across consecutive hide-and-seek rounds. | Storage Closet |
Main Story Badges
Completing the primary storyline unlocks five core progression badges across your journey from the farm to the bakery.
Out of the Fire
At the start of the adventure, lightning sets Applejack’s barn ablaze and scatters the livestock across the dirt pathway. Walk directly behind the roaming chickens to steer them up the wooden ramp into their coop before heading down the illuminated road to catch the train.
Out of the Woods
Fluttershy guides you along the dark railroad tracks while hostile forest branches reach out from the shadows. Follow the on-screen prompts to leap over fallen logs with your Jump key and slide beneath elevated branches by holding your Crouch key.
A Warm Welcome & Not Found
Follow Pinkie into Sugarcube Corner to register the welcome milestone, then assist with bakery preparations by timing the sugar weight scale mini-game. When Pinkie initiates hide-and-seek with a five-second countdown, dash inside an empty closet, shut the doors, and hold your breath using the interact prompt until she steps away.
Holding breath inside the closet while Pinkie Pie searches the bakery
Pinkie’s Party
Take a seat at the decorated dining table once Pinkie fires her celebratory party cannon. Hold your interact button to consume all four portions of the custom cupcake until your vision blurs and the screen fades to black, completing Chapter 1.
Failure Ending Badges
Unlocking every badge requires failing specific sequences to trigger alternate game-over screens.
Kindling
During the barn fire sequence, refuse to extinguish the flames with the well water. Stand completely still outside the burning structure until the internal timer elapses and the game confirms you failed to escape.
Lost in the Everfree
Start the Everfree Forest rail run and deliberately collide with incoming log barriers or tangled vines. The shadow creatures will catch up immediately, granting the failure badge on your retry screen.
Found You
Upon starting Chapter 2, roam the upstairs corridor until you spot Pinkie Pie patrolling between rooms. Stand directly in her line of sight without using party poppers so she scoops you up and sends you down the cellar chute.
Secrets 1 to 4: Barn and Railroad
The first four hidden discoveries take place during your encounters with Applejack and the Friendship Express train ride.
Secret 1: Somepony at the Window
When talking to Applejack inside the barn entrance the following morning, wait for the dialogue wheel to appear. Select the fourth option, “Was someone at the window?”, to make her mention the owl in the loft and trigger the discovery banner.
Selecting the window dialogue choice when talking to Applejack
Secret 2: Angry Applejack
Grab a wooden bucket from beside the courtyard well and press your interact key to fill it to the brim. Instead of dousing the flaming barn walls, aim at Applejack and splash her with water repeatedly until she yells at you to cool off inside the fire.
Secret 3: Somepony on the Train
While riding inside the train passenger car, listen for the conductor’s announcement regarding electrical interference from the surrounding woods. Look at the middle glass window on the left wall to see a faint smiley face etched into the condensation.
A smiley face drawn on the misty train passenger carriage window
Secret 4: Not Fire!
When the train halts beside the tracks, pick up the glowing metal lantern hanging by the carriage door and approach Fluttershy trapped in living brambles. Instead of collecting the requested blue glowcap mushrooms, press the lantern against her tangled vines to trigger an angry reaction from the foliage.
Secrets 5 to 9: Sugarcube Corner
The remaining five secrets require breaking rules, provoking bakery residents, and repeating evasive habits inside the main shop.
Secret 5: Spin Cycle
Locate Gummy the alligator resting beneath the green armchair near the party dining room. Approach his snout so he clamps onto your character, spinning you around the flooring before scurrying away into the bakery walls.
Secret 6: Wrong Answer
When Pinkie asks you to make an official promise at the bottom of the staircase, inspect the choice prompt. Choose “no” three times in a row until her cheerful expression twists into a wide grin and she triggers a jumpscare.
Secret 7: Broken Promise
Agree to Pinkie’s terms by selecting the “Pinkie promise” dialogue option during the hallway conversation. As soon as she heads upstairs to finish her secret preparations, run straight to the red double doors at the front entrance and attempt to open them.
Secret 8: I Dare You
When the objective instructs you to take a seat at the party table, ignore the chairs and sprint straight toward Pinkie Pie. Bump into her model repeatedly until she leans in close and warns you never to poke her again.
Secret 9: Creature of Habit
During the hide-and-seek minigame, sprint into the tall storage closet beside the counter and hold your breath to survive the first round. When the second round begins, immediately return to the exact same closet and hide inside it once more to finish your secret collection.