Getting the good ending in Witch You Want isn’t about speed or experimentation — it’s about precision. Every time you brew a potion for your boss, the exact ingredient combination matters, and even a single wrong component can ruin the result and push you toward a worse outcome.
To impress your boss and unlock the “Kiss the Chef” achievement along with the good ending, you must successfully craft all the correct potions throughout the game. Each one uses a specific three-ingredient formula, and the order doesn’t matter — only the exact ingredients do.
Below are all the correct combinations.
Perfect Potion Guide
The first potion requires combining a Cat’s Eye Gem, Peach Seeds, and a Bluebird Feather. This early recipe is straightforward but sets the tone for how precise later brews must be.
The second potion uses a calmer herbal mix. You need Lavender, Beeswax, and Mint to create the correct result.
For the third potion, the combination shifts slightly but stays within similar materials. The proper ingredients are Beeswax, Lavender, and Rose Petals.
The fourth potion mirrors the first one in terms of materials but is still treated as a separate step. To complete it, you again combine Peach Seeds, Bluebird Feather, and a Cat’s Eye Gem.
The fifth potion leans heavily into floral and herbal components. The correct mixture consists of Mint, Rose Petals, and Lavender.
For the sixth potion, you need a slightly different balance, mixing Peach Seeds, Rose Petals, and Mint.
The final potion is the one that determines whether you fully succeed. To brew it correctly, you must combine Rose Petals, a Cat’s Eye Gem, and Dandelion.
How These Affect the Ending
Successfully brewing every one of these potions is essential for reaching the good ending path. Missing even one recipe or using incorrect ingredients can lead to a different outcome and prevent you from earning the related achievement.
Because of this, it’s best to double-check each combination before brewing rather than relying on memory or guessing.